This morning Melissa de la Cruz tweeted about receiving a hateful email directed at her & her publisher. Her response was AWESOME: “The best revenge to someone who hates your books is to keep writing them.”
As authors, we get lots of scathing e-mails, reviews & even up close and personal comments. There will always be negative reviews because books are like ice cream. Everyone likes (and hates) different flavors. Personally, I don’t mind bad reviews as long as they aren’t personal. I think it’s important for people to share their ideas & opinions about books, music, even pie — as long as the reviews focus on the book, music, or pie and not the person who made it (unless said person made the pie & then smashed it into your face Lucy & Ethel style).
Margie is smarter than me. She just doesn’t read them. And I don’t read most reviews, but when I see an email in my in my inbox, I think, “Yay! Mail!” Then I open it & read it. Most of them don’t attack us personally, though many like to point out that I am very short and wear weird clothes. (This is true.)
The ones I can’t handle start with “You and Miss Stohl” (who btw is a Mrs.)… or “Your editor…” Our editor is THE BEST editor in the world (we all think this about our editors if they are awesome) & Margie is an insanely talented writer, with or without me. So I will gladly accept it if you think I suck, but I know they don’ t.
I get equally crazy when I see the work of any author I love trashed in a personal manner (which btw most professional reviews & bloggers don’t do).
Then I read something interesting that hit home. It claimed that most people who say things about others actually accuse others of the very thing they fear about themselves. It’s like the old saying that if someone is accusing you of cheating on them all the time, it’s probably because they’re doing it.
Some of these scathing emails I get come from other aspiring writers that are struggling themselves. Maybe they don’t have a great community of writers encouraging them, or friends to read their work and cheer them on? Writing is scary and lonely, and everyone needs support (and a thick skin). So if by chance, someone reading this is an aspiring writer who needs a community, I encourage you to check out these hashtags on Twitter:
#writetip
#YALitChat
#askagent
#amwriting
#askeditor
And if you still think I’m short & I dress weird, you can tell me. But I’ll probably think you’re short, too.
x K
That’s terrible that you get these type of e-mails from aspiring authors. We should not do that to each other. And I can’t believe you get any scathing e-mails because your books are so good. I think if people don’t have anything good to say about a book, they just shouldn’t say anything. And being polite isn’t asking too much.
Ok, I don’t even know if you’re, like, reading this or something, but I just wanted to say that I REALLY love your books and have been reading them non-stop since i found the first Beautiful Creatures book a few weeks ago. My dog died to day so I was sad, but then I was SO happy when I discovered that Beautiful creatures is going to be a MOVIE (!!!!), but, you know, then I was sad again, but it definitely cheered me up! So, i just wanted to say THANK YOU for writing!!!! It always makes me smile to read your books! 🙂
Definitely have to have a thick skin when writing and publishing.I agree that not every one is going to like your story, or even you personally. But I think too, that a little bit of the golden rule goes a long way. Do unto others as you would have done unto you. (Or perhaps it’s just those Southern roots of mine flaring up like Medusa’s hair.) Once upon a time I wrote in another genre, and reading reviews to me was always a double edged sword, and being curious as a cat didn’t help. I always tried to take reviews with a grain of salt. That being said maybe it’s better not read them (reviews) at all. Might be smarter that way. : )Love your books! They are set in the South, which Charleston is home for me so it seems all very nice and homey, except for the dark parts LOL. Keep up the good work!
I just got my very first one-star, scathing review. It was so mean-spirited and insulting I wasn’t sure what to do. I set out to write a blog post about how to deal with it and decided to check out how other, successful authors survive such negativity. That’s how I found this post.
Thanks for this. It’s nice to know I’m in such reputable company. I love your books and can’t wait for the movie!